(© djoronimo - stock.adobe.com)
ROCHESTER, Minn. — There’s no question that people are living longer today than centuries or even decades ago. However, in what might seem like a cruel irony, a new study finds people may not be living very well in those extra years.
The gap, which represents the difference between how long people live (lifespan) and how many of those years are spent in good health (healthspan), has widened to an average of 9.6 years worldwide. Even more striking, Americans now face the largest gap of any nation, spending an average of 12.4 years – or roughly the equivalent of the entire period between starting kindergarten and graduating high school – living with disease or disability at the end of their lives.
The research, conducted by scientists at Mayo Clinic, analyzed data from 183 World Health Organization (WHO) member states over two decades, painting a comprehensive picture of global health trends from 2000 to 2019. Their findings tell a story of medical progress that comes with an unexpected catch: while we’ve gotten better at keeping people alive, we haven’t been as successful at keeping them healthy.
Instead of celebrating vibrant golden years, however, more people find themselves navigating a landscape of chronic pain, mental health struggles, and persistent illness. Welcome to the new reality of aging in the 21st century.
The study, published in JAMA Network Open, are sobering. revealed a particularly troubling gender disparity. Women, who typically live longer than men, are paying a price for their longevity. Globally, women experience a healthspan-lifespan gap that is 2.4 years wider than men’s. This disparity peaks in certain countries, with German women facing a gap 3.6 years larger than their male counterparts.
“The data show that gains in longevity are not matched with equivalent advances in healthy longevity,” says Dr. Andre Terzic, the study’s senior author, in a media release. “Growing older often means more years of life burdened with disease.”
Think of it this way: if life were a long-distance race, we’ve successfully extended the track, but we’re forcing runners to hobble through an increasingly longer portion of the final lap. While medical advances have pushed the finish line further out, they haven’t necessarily made the journey more comfortable.
What’s driving this growing health gap? In the United States, mental health and substance use disorders top the list, followed closely by musculoskeletal conditions – things like arthritis, back pain, and other mobility-limiting ailments. Women bear a particularly heavy burden of these musculoskeletal problems, which helps explain their wider healthspan-lifespan gap.
The research presents an intriguing paradox: countries with higher life expectancies tend to have larger healthspan-lifespan gaps. This suggests that our success in extending life has inadvertently created a new challenge: a growing period of late-life disability that our healthcare systems weren’t designed to handle.
The findings also highlight stark global inequalities. While the United States, Australia, and New Zealand struggle with large healthspan-lifespan gaps (12.4, 12.1, and 11.8 years respectively), countries like Lesotho, the Central African Republic, and Somalia show much smaller gaps (6.5, 6.7, and 6.8 years). However, this isn’t necessarily good news for the latter group – their smaller gaps often reflect shorter overall lifespans rather than better health.
Over the two decades studied, global life expectancy increased by 6.5 years, but health-adjusted life expectancy only rose by 5.4 years. This growing disparity suggests that our medical systems have become better at preventing death than at preventing disability.
Rwanda, Malawi, and Burundi showed the most significant improvements in both lifespan and healthspan, while the Dominican Republic and Venezuela were the only countries to see declines in both measures. The United States, despite its advanced healthcare system, emerged as a cautionary tale, with its healthspan-lifespan gap growing from 10.9 to 12.4 years over the study period.
“The widening healthspan-lifespan gap globally points to the need for an accelerated pivot to proactive wellness-centric care systems,” explains Armin Garmany, the study’s first author.
As we stand at the threshold of what many call the “longevity revolution,” these findings serve as a crucial wake-up call. Living longer is only half the battle – the real challenge lies in ensuring those extra years are worth living. Perhaps it’s time to shift our focus from simply extending life to expanding the portion of life lived in good health.
After all, in the race against time, maybe the goal isn’t just to run longer, but to finish strong.
Paper Summary
Methodology
The researchers utilized comprehensive data from the World Health Organization’s Global Health Observatory, examining health trends from 2000 to 2019. They calculated a “health-adjusted life expectancy” by measuring the years people live without disability, then compared this to total life expectancy to determine the “health gap.”
Key Results
The study found that life expectancy increased by 6.5 years during the two-decade period, but health-adjusted life expectancy rose by only 5.4 years. This means people are living longer, but not necessarily healthier.
In the United States, the health gap widened dramatically. Women’s life expectancy increased from 79.2 to 80.7 years, while men’s rose from 74.1 to 76.3 years. However, health-adjusted life expectancy remained virtually unchanged for women and increased minimally for men.
Mental health disorders, substance abuse, and musculoskeletal conditions emerged as major contributors to the health gap, particularly in the United States.
Study Limitations
The researchers acknowledged several limitations. The health gap calculations depend on disability weights assigned to various health conditions, which can be influenced by survey methods and the potential over-representation of unaffected individuals.
Discussion & Takeaways
The findings underscore a critical global challenge: as medical advances help us live longer, we’re not necessarily living better. The widening health gap suggests an urgent need to shift from treating diseases to preventing them.
The study highlights the importance of proactive wellness strategies. Instead of simply extending life, healthcare systems should focus on maintaining quality of life throughout aging.
Funding & Disclosures
The research was supported by the Marriott Family Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, and the National Institute of General Medical Sciences. The authors reported no conflicts of interest.
Don’t generalize on the human race from observations about Americans. Many, many countries are now living longer with MORE good years at the end. America is going backwards. Obesity and a culture that does not value the elderly are to blame.